By John English, CEO, Leadership Trust
The most senior person in the room is usually the last to know how they are really coming across.
I don't say that as a criticism. Most senior leaders are perceptive people who built their careers partly on reading situations well. What changes as someone rises isn't their judgement, it's the information reaching them about their own impact.
Think about what it actually takes to tell a chief executive their decision-making shut down debate before it started, or to tell a divisional director their feedback style makes people perform to order rather than think. The information might be accurate and useful. For the person delivering it, it's also a risk. They're not just weighing whether it's true. They're weighing what it costs them if the leader reacts badly, remembers who said it, or stops trusting them with the next opportunity that comes up. Most people decide it isn't worth it. So, they edit or sanitise their feedback, or they say nothing at all.
Nobody involved usually experiences this as withholding. Status changes what gets said in a room more than most leaders assume, and it does so beneath conscious awareness on both sides. To the person staying quiet, it simply feels like good judgement about what's worth raising.
The effect compounds. A first-time manager still gets plenty of unfiltered feedback, often more than they'd like. A leader a decade into their career has, without anyone deciding this on purpose, been moved onto a diet of curated information: agreement, softened concern, problems that have already been smoothed over by the time they arrive. Executive isolation is rarely one dramatic event. It builds from thousands of small, entirely reasonable decisions by other people not to say the difficult thing.
In my work with the Leadership Trust I've watched what this costs organisations. A leader working from a distorted picture of their own impact makes worse calls about who to promote, which conflicts actually need their attention, and when their own approach, not the market or the competition, is the real constraint on their team. Boards spend a great deal of time and money addressing the downstream symptoms, disengagement, attrition, decisions that stall, without always tracing them back to a leader who has simply stopped receiving accurate signal about themselves. Or perhaps how the Board itself is operating and communicating with themselves and the leader.
The usual fix is to formalise feedback: engagement surveys, upward reviews, 360 tools. These help. They also run into the same problem they're meant to solve. An anonymous survey still asks someone to trust their honesty won't eventually be traced back to them. A 360 process still asks a direct report to rate their own boss on a form that boss's team may end up seeing. The mechanism looks more objective. The calculation the person filling it in is making hasn't changed at all.
What actually changes it isn't the process. It's how the leader shows up. I've watched a chief executive struggling with the same physical challenge as everyone else, admitting they don't have the answer, asking for help in front of the group, and watched the room's ordinary hierarchy gradually stop operating while it happens. People have said things to that person's face on day three that they would never have raised back in the office, not because anything about the room protected them, but because the leader went first.
This isn't a story about bad leaders surrounded by flatterers. Almost nobody involved intends to distort the picture reaching the top. And most leaders do want to hear feedback that will help improve their performance. That's what makes it hard to fix from the inside. It's the accumulated, well-meant caution of everyone around a powerful person, each decision reasonable on its own, expensive in total.
The leaders I've seen handle this well don't treat a facilitated session or time out on a leadership development programme as the final fix. They treat those as the moments they finally see what honesty actually costs the people around them, and they come back and do the harder, longer work of making it cost less, in their own team, every week, not once a year.
That is the work that actually changes an organisation.